- Highland Spring100
- Brecon Carreg90
- Thirsty Planet86
Click here for more detailed table
In the mineral industry, the multinationals are in charge – even when it comes to brands such as Malvern and Buxton. In fact, all the world-wide market leaders (Evian, Volvic, Perrier and San Pellegrino) are under the control of either Danone or Nestle. These companies have faced serious criticism in recent years. Additionally, the Bottled Water industry is often criticized for being wasteful, unsustainable and misleading.
Though it is always more ethical to drink tap water and to use re-usable bottles, if you find yourself out and about and in need of a drink, there are alternative Bottled Water brands which do score highly on the Ethical Company Index.
Try and choose the most local brand you can find – those that are sourced in the UK and therefore have a much smaller carbon footprint.
Every bottle of Perrier sold around the world is bottled at source in Vergèze, France. Readers in, say, Glasgow, could be drinking water that has travelled over 900 miles.
An environmental packaging solution is the re-usable glass bottle. In other European countries, such as Germany, higher proportions of all drinks come in returnable bottles. The bottled water producers are members of a pool system, with their brands being distinguished by label but the bottles shared, allowing short transport distances from individual to refiller.
In the UK, it seems that the big national breweries, soft drinks producers and supermarkets are reluctant to use refillable glass bottles because of the extra effort (floor space and staff time) it would cause them. They would rather deal with plastics and prefer to encourage recycling, which hands the work over to the individual. Most councils will collect bottles bearing the numbers one (PET) or two (HDPE), but it is still difficult to find a recycling point for any other type of plastic.
Pure, but how pure?
Although bottled water claims a natural, pure and healthy image, all waters must meet strict quality requirements. The area surrounding a Natural Mineral Water spring requires protection against pollution, and although Natural Mineral Water is legally ‘pure’, this is not true of all water that is sold in bottles.
When you look at the rows of bottled water in supermarkets (there are up to forty varieties) whose purity is emphasised by waterfalls and mountains, it’s easy to forget the complexity of treatment that some water from a source goes through before being bottled.
Those with high blood pressure, or others who need to follow a low sodium (salt) diet should check the mineral content of their water carefully. Natural mineral waters can only claim they’re suitable for a low sodium diet if they contain less than 20mg per litre. Current advice from the Food Standards Agency is that some bottled waters shouldn’t be used for babies: ‘Waters to avoid are those with high levels of nitrite, sodium, fluoride and sulphate. There are limits for these in tap, spring and other bottled drinking waters, but not in natural mineral waters.’
Choose the right brand!
We recommend Highland Spring as they have a clean ethical record and Brecon Carreg which sets ambitious environmental targets. Both are local to the UK (our location), and score very highly on the Ethical Company Index (especially when compared to other leading brands like Evian, Buxton and Volvic). Highland Spring and Brecon Carreg are also the only bottled water brands to become Ethical Accreditation members and as such are regularly audited every 12 months.
Other ethical brands to look out for are One Water and Life – both brands fund clean drinking water projects in developing countries.
There has been much cynicism about the bottled water industry from some quarters. A report by the Canadian non-governmental Polaris Institute (www.polarisinstitute.org) argued that the big companies pay next to nothing for water they take from rural springs or public water systems, and, after turning water into water through elaborate treatment processes, sell a product that is not as well-regulated as tap water, but is vastly more expensive.
For instance, in 2004 Coca Cola launched Dasani, a new brand of bottled water. Although the water was actually drawn from the mains (Thames Water in fact), Coca Cola talked of a ‘highly sophisticated’, Volvic spacecraft technology. It emerged, however, that this was simply reverse osmosis, used in many domestic water purification units. Then, to complete the PR catastrophe, 500,000 litres of the brand had to be recalled from British supermarkets because of high levels of bromate, a cancer-causing chemical which is not found in Thames Water.
Mix it up
The Drinking Water Inspectorate has warned that if opportunities are not taken to improve public perception of tap water, people will never appreciate the plentiful low cost water supplied to their taps. So don’t be afraid to ask for tap water as it is very healthy too.
Ethical Comparison – Bottled Water Rankings Detailed Table
Buy our detailed Ethical Research Reports. See the findings behind companies’ ethical ratings, as featured in The Good Shopping Guide. Several different product sectors available covering hundreds of consumer brands.
We have created ethical comparison rankings for the following brands, based on the activities of the company group (see above tables): Highland Spring, Ballygowan, Campsie Spring, Life, One, Harrogate, Hildon, Strathmore, Thirsty Planet, Brecon Carreg, Deeside, Willow, Isklar, Badoit, Evian, Volvic, Iceni, Aqua Pura, Buxton, Perrier, Pure Life, San Pellegrino, Vittel
Did you find this research helpful? Please consider donating, and keep this website free.
LAST UPDATED: 2016